Stats

  • Locked Locked
  • Replies 10
  • Subscribers 144
  • Views 2827
  • Members are here 0
This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

args _args

linbo

Can't find definitions or explanation of these two terms in cds documentation.  Could someone help (either with explanation or point me to documentation?)

 

Thanks in advance,

--lin

  •  Hi Lin,

    typically "args" would be used with something like a trigger function that automatically supplies arguments to the user-defined function.  In such situations "args" is used to gather input data in a structure, usually a disembodied property list.  For the purposes of SKILL Lint checking, if this argument is not used or referred to in the function, it would normally generate a warning (since the argument must be present, since this is how the trigger function is invoked by the tools), so here we can use "_args" to indicate that the argument is present, but we intentionally do not access it in the code.

    I hope that this explains things and answers your questions?

    Regards,

    Lawrence.

  • Hi Lin,

    In what context are you using these terms? I don't know what they mean otherwise...
    Put another way, why are you asking the question? What is it that you need to know?

    Regards,

    Andrew

  •  Hi Andrew,

    I'm trying to understand building custom menus.  I've seen two examples in the user forums, one uses args, the other uses _args.

     

    Thanks,

    --lin

  • Hi Lin,

    It would help if you gave a link to what you've seen - because there's almost certainly no special meaning to the word "args" or "_args" (other than the conventions Lawrence mentioned). In the context of a specific example, we can probably elaborate with more detail.

    Regards,

    Andrew

  •  Maybe he wants to say, that when we use variable name without underscore, then it local variable if we use variable name with underscore, then we want to show, that it member of calss?

  • That's not it. The name of a variable does not imply whether it's local or whether it's a "member of a class" (I assume you meant to say "class"). Not sure why you thought that.

    This is almost certainly a reference to a specific example - but without knowing what the specific example is, it's rather hard to comment!

    Andrew.

  •  Yes, I mean class. The question is, that sometimes some people use style, when if variable name begining with underscore _myVariable or m_myVariable they want to say, that it variable is class member.

  • That is not a convention that's typically used for SKILL though. If a global variable or function begins with underscore, that is generally meant to imply that it is private (underscore followed by a prefix; Cadence users lowercase prefixes, whereas users should use prefixes that begin with uppercase).

    For function arguments, prefixing the name with underscore is meant to imply that the argument is intentionally not used - this is done in the case that Lawrence described where you have some trigger which requires an argument to be present, but you don't need to use it inside. SKILL Lint looks for such scenarios and uses this convention to disable the warning you'd otherwise get about unused arguments.

    Regards,

    Andrew.

  •  Hi Andrew,

     

    The context I found these in was on the forum talking about custom layout menus.  Here's the link to that thread:

    http://www.cadence.com/Community/forums/p/17476/1245483.aspx#1245483

    skilluser from Austin posts his solution...

    procedure(AmitAddMenu(args)

    and you post your solution... 

    procedure(AmitAddMenu(_args)

    I was trying to discern why one would use the _ or not...

    Thanks!

    --lin

     

  • Hi Lin,

    In that specific case you may note that Andrew's method (the correct approach) used a userMenuTrigger and because it is a trigger function it will be supplied a dpl structure with information in it, but the code did not need any of this information so there was no access to the "args" structure/variable, so the argument is renamed to _args so that SKILL Lint does not complain about the function argument being supplied but not used.  In my code example I accessed the window id from the structure passed in, and so I did use "args" within the procedure body, so Lint would not have complained about that, hence no need for the underscore preceding the variable name.

    Hopefully this explains why for this example, but Andrew's earlier post was clear I thought too.

    Regards,

    Lawrence.

Community Guidelines

The Cadence Design Communities support Cadence users and technologists interacting to exchange ideas, news, technical information, and best practices to solve problems and get the most from Cadence technology. The community is open to everyone, and to provide the most value, we require participants to follow our Community Guidelines that facilitate a quality exchange of ideas and information. By accessing, contributing, using or downloading any materials from the site, you agree to be bound by the full Community Guidelines.